Short Sales – Why isn’t anyone talking about what happens to your client after close of escrow?

By Kim Brooks

Let’s talk “short sales”…every expert seems to have a different or better solution to the doom and gloom of a short sale. As everyone is aware, each and every transaction is a totally different animal, dependent on the bank, the hardship, the title company, the Realtor, the lender, the seller…this isn’t new news. So instead of talking about how stressful, challenging and sometimes depressing the process is, I thought I would share a personal story that “just may” be able to help you and your sellers….in the current market and in the future because, “This too shall Pass.”

I have a friend that endured a legitimate hardship in 2008, due to divorce and loss of income. In 2008 before loan modifications?, government programs, etc., basically you had one choice, walk away or short sale. My friend had stellar credit, unfortunately like thousands of other households could no longer maintain her obligation. She called the bank months before seeking assistance, her voice was never heard…she was current so what’s the problem??

After consulting with a real estate attorney that told her to just walk away (the seller had a 1st & amp; 2nd – non-purchase money?), she consulted a Realtor. The Realtor advised to try to short sale. The home was impeccable, listed on a Friday and sold on Monday, Canadian/cash buyer. The property closed in 90 days..start to finish. This wouldn’t have happened if it wasn’t for her Realtor who spent hours on end on the phone with both banks, etc. etc. (you know how the story goes). So, things are different now, HAFA, HAMP, loan mods, etc…..but how did this transaction really effect her credit? It’s now 2011…

I hear all the time, a short sale will only drop your score maybe…80 points? Isn’t every situation, just like every transaction different?? A short sale is better for your credit than a foreclosure…but personally, I wouldn’t advise further (though I’m NOT the expert..just an opinion). My friends credit score dropped from a 780 to low 500′s, while she maintained and is still current on all of her other obligations. She also received a letter from the 2nd that gave her FULL release of any future liability or interest in the property, due to the fact that the 1st lien holder, seller and buyer came to the closing table with cash, more than the 1st gave(and a great Realtor).

FAST FORWARD….2011. You should be able to purchase an FHA home 2 years after a short sale or is it 3 years? Is that really the case? If you have an opinion, please share! Since 2008, once a year she is contacted by an attorney or the bank that is trying to collect the debt on the 2nd,, which was settled in 2008. She pulls the letter out of her files and faxes it to them,, then sends letters to all 3 credit bureau’s including the letter from the bank and the HUD-1.,, the debt collector disappears for another year, then they’re back! A new one this time…the cycle starts over. May 2010 her credit was high 500′s, Sept. 2010, mid-high 600′s. So, though the debt was forgiven and she is able to manage her affairs, the transaction is still having a significant effect on her life. So when does it end…or better yet does it ever end?? How does the story end……

Being in the title industry, we deal with short sales all day might say “experts”. I haven’t seen many lenders giving a full release, letter, etc., more like a promissory note with the sellers signature to allow the bank to “try” to collect the debt at any time. I am privileged to work with professionals and so are your buyers and sellers!

So, hence the reason I wrote this, I feel like it’s an important topic that we may not be talking about now…but we sure will be somewhere down the road!! I can’t help to think that Collections will be a very lucrative business in the future!!

Thank you for reading, would love your feedback… on just some of my random thoughts!


Leave Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked


  • In my experience, the quality of service delivered by Magnus Title is unsurpassed in the industry. Their team is professional, thorough and responsive....

    Sue Bentley
    Designated Broker/Owner Coldwell Banker Bentley
  • I have been a client of Magnus – Ocotillo Branch for two years and they are fantastic! The Magnus team is always available to answer questions and they...

    Henry Wang
    West USA Realty Revelation
  • I like doing business with Magnus Title because they are efficient and quick. I appreciate that I can provide Magnus with a contract and I receive immediate...

    Marty Recht
    West USA Revelation
  • Who we are in business with is one of the most important decisions that we make. The most important decision being our spouse or significant other. The...

    Barry Kramer
    Designated Broker/Operating Principal Keller Williams Realty Sonoran Living Ahwatukee/Scottsdale/Paradise Valley
  • I’m most impressed with Magnus Title’s communication and responsiveness. They respond to my needs as though they were part of my team. Therefore…...

    Kevin Craig
    S4 Team Keller Williams Sonoran Living